Top 10 Best Graco Pack N Play Mattress Picks Reviewed for 2022
“As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases”
The thin hard pad that comes with the Graco Pack N Play is not comfortable for your child to sleep on. To ensure that your child sleeps comfortably, replacing the hard firm mattress pad with another soft mattress is ideal. There are many mattresses that are on the market which fit the Graco Pack N Play.
Some of the mattresses are made of foam while others have coils similar to those on an innerspring mattress. A mattress with coils will offer more support, but a memory foam mattress will gently conform to your child's body.
It is up to parents to choose the best mattress for their child based on personal preferences and the information that is available on different brands of mattresses that fit the Graco Pack 'n Play. A parent needs to be aware of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) and they type of pack and play mattresses that are best designed with the baby's safety and health in mind.
Choosing which new mattress to buy is difficult with so much information about different brands of mattresses available online. Many parents don’t have the time and energy to research a bunch of different mattress brands or baby products while going through their busy lives.
To make it easy for parents to find a comfortable mattress for their Graco Pack N Play playards, we have researched, picked then reviewed the ten best mattresses that fit the Graco Pack N Play perfectly.
PRODUCT | DETAILS | RATING |
|---|---|---|
 Dream On Me- Foam Pack and Play Mattress | ||
 Dream On Me 3" Playard Mattress | ||
 Milliard Classic | ||
Dream On Me - 3" Pocket Coil Graco Pack 'n Play Mattress | ||
 hiccapop |
OUR #1 RATED - Dream On Me Foam Pack and Play Mattress
The Dream On Me mattress for the Graco Pack N Play is made of 10% vinyl and 90% foam. This mattress cradles the body and provides ultimate comfort during your little one's sleep. It is excellent for side sleepers that need extra support.
This mattress has perimeter wide border wires and lock stitch binding to maintain its shape and prevent unraveling as a safety feature.
The Dream On Me Mattress has an easy to wipe, hypoallergenic, antibacterial waterproof cover that is stain resistant. The lock stitched binding on its edges helps prevent against leaks from reaching the mattress and hence prevent mold, mildew and strange odors finding a home inside it.
The mattress fits the Graco Pack N Play Snuggle Sweet LX Play yard, the Graco Pack N Play from the Pasadena Collection, the Graco Day2Night sleep system.
PROS
CONS
RUNNER UP - Dream On Me 3" Playard Mattress
The Dream On Me 3 inch Playard mattress is made of 10% vinyl and 90% foam. The mattress has a vinyl cover for durability that is waterproof and is easy to wipe clean. This mattress is hypoallergenic, antibacterial, and helps prevent against mold, mildew, and strange odors.
The Dream On Me 3-inch mattress is Greenguard certified for low chemical emissions. The mattress is lightweight and portable and is made to fit the Graco Day2Night Sleep System, Graco Pack N Play Playard with automatic folding feet, Snuggle Sweet LX and Pasadena collection.
For information on more playards where this mattress can fit check out the vendor's list as not all mattresses will fit into all pack and plays.
Note that this mattress should never be placed on the top level of the playard in the bassinet position.
PROS
CONS
Best Value - Milliard Classic
The Milliard Classic Pack N' Play Mattress provides comfort, safety, function in one high-quality mattress. This mattress is made from a top-quality high-density memory foam that provides comfort and support for a great night’s sleep.
For easy cleanup, a waterproof, removable and washable cover is included. The cover keeps your mattress safe from liquids that could promote mildew or mold. Though this mattress is not foldable it can be rolled up for travel if needed.
This Milliard memory foam pack and play mattress is CertiPUR-US certified free of toxins and has a full fireproof lining. It fits perfectly inside the Graco playard.
However though, this dense foam mattress is not recommended for babies but for toddlers and up. It is recommended after receiving and unpacking this mattress to allow 24 to 48 hours for the mattress to fully expand before use.
PROS
CONS
Best Supportive - Dream On Me 3" Pocket Coil Graco Pack 'n Play Mattress
The Milliard Classic Pack N' Play Mattress provides comfort, safety, function in one high-quality mattress. This mattress is made from a top-quality high-density foam that provides comfort and support for a great night’s sleep.
For easy cleanup, a waterproof, removable and washable cover is included. The cover keeps your mattress safe from liquids that could promote mildew or mold. Though this mattress is not foldable it can be rolled up for travel if needed.
This mattress is CertiPUR-US certified free of toxins for your baby's health and has a full fireproof lining for safety. This mattress fits perfectly inside the pack and play. This mattress is not recommended for babies but for toddlers and up. It is recommended after receiving and unpacking this mattress to allow 24 to 48 hours for it to fully expand before use.
PROS
CONS
Best Portable - hiccapop
The Tri-fold Pack N Play mattress pad by hiccapop is dual-sided with a firm side for infant babies and a soft side for newborn baby toddlers. The mattress pad includes a washable cover that is hypoallergenic, stain-resistant, helps prevent mold, mildew, and strange orders.
It has rounded corners to ensure that it fits perfectly inside your Graco Pack N Play without leaving any gaps. These round corners also mean that nobody will be losing anything as there will be no gaps around it.
The strong edge support it has mean that your baby's body will be well supported anywhere on the mattress.
The hiccapop Trifold Pack N Play mattress folds into thirds and is easily portable. The mattress weighs 4.24 pounds and comes with a beautiful carry case travel bag to transport the mattress pad easily. The hiccapop Pack N Play mattress replacement fits all standard pack and play brands like Baby Trend and Evenflo that are size 38” x 26”.
PROS
CONS
#6 - Dream On Me Breathable Mattress
The Dream On Me - 3 Inch Breathable Two-Sided Square Corner Play Yard Mattress is made from 10% vinyl and 90% foam. It is made in the USA and includes a waterproof cover that is stain resistant and is easy to wipe clean.
This mattress is CertiPUR-US certified as toxin-free and is hypoallergenic. This mattress is for babies sizes 3lbs to 25lbs and fits select playards.
PROS
CONS
#7 - Milliard Pack N' Play Mattress Topper
The Milliard Tri-fold Pack N Play Mattress Topper is a thick and soft memory foam mattress that is meant to replace the thin, hard pack and play mattress pad that comes with the playard.
The mattress includes a waterproof cover that is removable for washing and fights mold, mildew and strange odors. The Milliard Tri-foldable Pack N Play mattresses fold into thirds for easy transport and include a bonus carry case to make it easy for you to take the mattress with you.
The Milliard mattress is CertiPUR-US certified toxin-free and includes a full fireproof lining as a safety feature. The mattress is not recommended for babies but for toddlers and older babies.
PROS
CONS
#8 - Little One's Pad
The Little One’s Pad Pack N Play Crib Mattress Cover is soft and comfortable. This pad has a waterproof lining and is durable due to reinforced threads. Note that it is 5 inches thick, so it is not a thin mattress pad.
It is machine washable and can be washed multiple times without shrinking. It has a breathable cover and will help your baby have a soothing night’s sleep without over-sweating. If you are looking for a pack and play thick mattress though, this product is not for you.
PROS
CONS
#9 - Sproutwise Kids
The folding Pack N Play mattresses from Sproutwise kids have very good support for the sleeping baby as they are made with a latex material core. They come with machine washable organic cotton covers that do not have any polyester blend anywhere on it.
This baby's mattress folds into thirds for easy travel and includes a cloth carry bag. It fits most Pack N Plays that are 24 to 26 inches wide. This mattress fits the Graco playard and is a great choice if you travel a lot and are looking for portable foldable pack and play mattresses. To verify if it will fit other pack and play crib brands you should check with the vendor.
PROS
CONS
#10 - Kolcraft Cozy Soft Portable Crib Mattress
The portable crib mattress by Kol craft is made of thick polyester. The entire mattress is soft, comfortable, and firm. It is made for portable cribs and mini cribs. Do not use this mattress with soft-sided playards.
This Graco Pack N Play replacement mattress comes with a removable waterproof, stain-resistant cover that is easy to wipe clean and fights against mold mildew and other strange orders. Ensure though that you do not use it in portable cribs with inside dimensions greater than 24.5” X 38.5.”
PROS
CONS
Buying Guide for Graco Pack N Play Playard Mattresses
The Graco Pack 'n Play Playard provides everything you need to keep your baby or toddler happy and safe at home and on the road except for a comfortable, easy-to-carry mattress. As previously mentioned, the unit's thin base pad offers little in terms of thickness and comfort for a crib mattress. But there are more important factors besides this and whether it costs too much money or not, that you should have on your checklist before you make your buying decision.
- What Size Mattress Fits a Graco Pack 'n Play?
It goes without saying that you need a Pack N Play mattress that will fit. Pack n play mattresses are typically 37.5” long by 25.5” wide. We however recommend that you measure your individual pack n play before getting a mattress, as there may be some little discrepancies. The thicknesses range from 1 to 3 inches. Avoid getting a crib mattress that is any thinner than that, as the lack of padding may be painful for newborns. - Materials
The best materials include high density foam, memory foam and metal spring coils with a permanent base cover and a removable cover. Some mattresses offer a combination of these materials, such as two-inch dense foam or coils on one side and memory foam on the other, for the most comfort. Most pack and play mattresses available are made of foam though to create a comfy, yet firm sleeping surface. That said, always look at what materials the mattress is made out of and pick a model with higher firmness. This guarantees comfort. Besides that, too much cushioning poses a danger of suffocation and SIDS. - Durability
You need to balance mattress material durability against comfort and weight. This factor is especially important if you plan to have more than one child since most mattresses will suffice until your child outgrows them. If this is the case, look for a firm, sturdy and well-made mattress. To back it up, buy a mattress with a good warranty package in case of any faults. However keep in mind that a more durable mattress that doesn't wear or tear easily might not be as portable. For example, spring coil mattresses are often more durable than lightweight foam, but they're also heavier. - Health - Skin Sensitivity and Allergic Reactions
Baby’s skin is so delicate and should not be exposed to harsh materials. Some babies also have allergies to certain materials. The best mattresses will usually be manufactured using green processes that leave behind few-to-no harmful chemicals on surfaces. The mattress materials don't outgas or contain toxins, especially phthalates or lead. To protect your child's skin from irritations and reduce allergy-related reactions, choose a Pack N Play mattress made with hypoallergenic materials, especially one that features a breathable, removable cover that's resistant to odors and growth of bacteria and other microorganisms. Also make sure that it is easy to clean to reduce dust accumulation. If you like having a mattress protector, ensure that it too is hypoallergenic. - Flammability
The mattress must meet federal safety testing standards designed to prevent the sale of furniture materials that burn easily or release toxic chemicals when ignited. All mattresses sold in the United States must meet at least the 16 CFR Part 1632 Standard for the Flammability of Mattresses and Mattress Pads and the 1633 Standard for the Flammability of Mattress Sets. Check the label or product description. Just like adult mattresses, you must purchase a mattress that passes these fire-proofing laws. Organic mattresses particularly contain safe, non-toxic fire retardant materials. Considering babies will be on the mattress for the major part of their day, it is better to be safe than sorry since accidents are unpredictable. - Portability
Last but not least, any mattress that you choose must allow for easy transportation, which means that you should consider small, lightweight options. Materials like canvas, vinyl and metal springs increase mattress weight. Materials like cotton and foam reduce weight. The most portable mattress designs offer easy-to-grip sides or handles or roll up to fit into a carry strap harness or bag.
The convenience of a fold-and-go mattress design will come in handy for an active lifestyle. You can easily pack and carry the mattress around to ensure that your child always has a place to sleep and play even when traveling.
If the comfort of your baby is a priority, you'll most likely dislike the thin pad that comes with your Graco pack n play. As such, you'll want to replace it with a good, comfortable mattress. With these 6 factors to consider, you are guaranteed the perfect choice!
FINAL THOUGHTS: Best Graco Pack and Play Mattress
All of these top 10 best mattresses on this list fit the Graco Pack and Play and most standard 36”x26” size mattress designs of the leading pack and play brands. They are all good choices, but the one mattress that stands out above the rest is hiccapop Tri-Fold mattress. It offers support and comfort for both toddlers and babies.
The mattress is dual-sided, extra thick and made from high quality materials. Use the firm side to provide support for babies and use the softer side for toddlers. It folds into thirds and comes with storage case so it can travel with you anywhere.
Further, the hiccapop Trifold Pack N Play Mattresses are CertiPUR-US Certified from all toxins and come with stain resistant plush Jacquard cover that is removable for easy cleaning in the washing machine.
We highly recommend that you try the hiccapop Pack n Play Mattress. This one is just not the best amongst folding mattresses but it is very a portable, dual-sided mattress for both babies and toddlers that comes with a lifetime guarantee. SleepRex.com does not provide medical advice.
He is an Engineer, designer and jogging enthusiast. His team of product testers and reviewers are as passionate as he is about sleep improvement and are on a collective mission to reveal to you only the best sleep solutions and products.
